Let’s Play Pretend | Masterlist

*This fic is a member exclusive*

Summary: It’s your eighteenth birthday, your dad promised you he would be back to celebrate with you and Dean, and like an absolute idiot you had believed him. You shouldn’t be surprised, he’d never shown up for things like your birthday before. Maybe it’s time to cut your losses and admit to yourself that he doesn’t really care; you’ll never be good enough for him, or anyone else for that matter.

Pairing: Dean x Sister!Reader

Rating: 18+

Warnings: Memory of sexual abuse of a minor – Victim Unaware, Dubious Consent, Sibling Incest, Predatory Dean

Tags: angst, age difference (Dean is 14 years older), daddy issues, abandonment issues, hurt/comfort, in a sick and twisted way, virgin!Reader, seeking validation, drunk kissing, daddy!kink, daddy!dean, incest kink, praise kink, body worship, nipple play, age play, DD/lg, possessive!Dean, shy!reader, innocence kink, oral sex, orgasm, p in v, aftercare, emotional manipulation, somnophilia

Word Count: 12.3k

A/N:  I want to reiterate the importance of reading the warnings for this chapter. Dean is a bad man. He did a bad thing. The recollection of previous sexual abuse is told from Dean’s POV and while he does know it was wrong, he also justifies and romanticises his actions to himself. Please do not read if this could be triggering for you. Of course, it goes without saying that I do not support or condone his actions in any way. This is a work of fiction.

Part 1

Part 2

Part 3

Not a member yet?