Y/N goes to visit Auggie during Thanksgiving break because he and Stella have been fighting pretty badly. Her hope is that if she helps him reconcile with his sister, he could have a reason to show Y/N just how thankful he is... but when Y/N arrives at Walker Ranch on Thanksgiving she doesn’t wind up kissing the Walker she had hoped to be kissing, and it turns out nobody is allowed to spend Thanksgiving at the Walker’s without leaving absolutely stuffed.
Tag: Virgin!Reader
Let’s Play Pretend | Masterlist
It’s your eighteenth birthday, your dad promised you he would be back to celebrate with you and Dean, and like an absolute idiot you had believed him. You shouldn’t be surprised, he’d never shown up for things like your birthday before. Maybe it’s time to cut your losses and admit to yourself that he doesn’t really care; you’ll never be good enough for him, or anyone else for that matter.
Let’s Play Pretend | Part 3
It’s your eighteenth birthday, your dad promised you he would be back to celebrate with you and Dean, and like an absolute idiot you had believed him. You shouldn’t be surprised, he’d never shown up for things like your birthday before. Maybe it’s time to cut your losses and admit to yourself that he doesn’t really care; you’ll never be good enough for him, or anyone else for that matter.
Let’s Play Pretend | Part 2
It’s your eighteenth birthday, your dad promised you he would be back to celebrate with you and Dean, and like an absolute idiot you had believed him. You shouldn’t be surprised, he’d never shown up for things like your birthday before. Maybe it’s time to cut your losses and admit to yourself that he doesn’t really care; you’ll never be good enough for him, or anyone else for that matter.
Let’s Play Pretend | Part 1
It’s your eighteenth birthday, your dad promised you he would be back to celebrate with you and Dean, and like an absolute idiot you had believed him. You shouldn’t be surprised, he’d never shown up for things like your birthday before. Maybe it’s time to cut your losses and admit to yourself that he doesn’t really care; you’ll never be good enough for him, or anyone else for that matter.
Show Me | Part 6
Jack goes to Sam and Dean for advice about girls and sex, and Sam turns out to be an excellent teacher.
Show Me | Part 5
Jack goes to Sam and Dean for advice about girls and sex, and Sam turns out to be an excellent teacher.
Show Me | Part 4
Jack goes to Sam and Dean for advice about girls and sex, and Sam turns out to be an excellent teacher.
Show Me | Part 3
Jack goes to Sam and Dean for advice about girls and sex, and Sam turns out to be an excellent teacher.
Show Me | Part 2
Jack goes to Sam and Dean for advice about girls and sex, and Sam turns out to be an excellent teacher.


